Sponsored by
Catholic Knights
Milwaukee Catholic Herald Subscribe to the Milwaukee Catholic Herald
Food for the Poor
Information about Milwaukee Catholic Herald Links Related to the Catholic Herald Catholic Herald Classifieds Catholic School/Parish Sports Listings Catholic School/Parish Sports Listings Catholic Herald Advertising
Milwaukee Catholic Herald Home Page
Herald of hope
National and World Catholic News Links
Past Catholic Herald Issues
Photos of the Week
Submit Information
St. Ann Center
Rosalie Manor
Capri Communities
Dec. 18, 2003
Vocations office looks for leaders
Committee aims to encourage young,
black men to pursue priesthood
By Candy Czernicki
Catholic Herald Staff
ONE OF A FEW — Fr. Bryan Massingale, one of only three African-American priests ordained for the archdiocese and the only one currently serving here, greets a parishioner at All Saints Church in Milwaukee. The archdiocesan vocations office has put together an 11-member committee to study ways of getting more African-American young men into the priesthood. (Catholic Herald photo by James Pearson)
MILWAUKEE — The demographic trend toward more Catholics with fewer priests to serve them has carried over to the African-American community as well.

The African-American population in the Milwaukee Archdiocese increased by 10 percent between 1990 and 2000. The last African-American priest for the archdiocese was ordained in 1986. There are none currently in formation.

Archdiocesan vocations director Fr. Bob Stiefvater has hand-picked an 11-member committee, which includes members of archdiocesan parishes and central offices, to address the issue. While they first met as a group in early summer, Fr. Stiefvater said the idea began more than seven years ago.

“There was a group of people ... when I first started this job, they called themselves the Black Clergy and Religious Support Caucus,” he said. “I met with them, came up with an action plan, we came up with a brochure specifically oriented to the African-American community. It had pictures of African-Americans working in the 10-county archdiocese. When I would interview young men and women, they would say, ‘Yeah, I would be all alone, I don’t know anybody.’ When I passed out (the brochures), they would be pointing out all the people they would know. That kind of came out of our plan seven years ago, but we wanted to put together a new plan to reach young people at decision-making points in their lives in the African-American community.”

The committee looks for young people with the gift of servant leadership, according to Schauneille Allen, a committee member and director of the archdiocesan African-American Ministry Office.

“We want someone who shows leadership and compassion but, most importantly, has a desire to serve,” Allen said.

Allen said that there has been talk about the best way for the committee to collaborate with her office on some of the programs the African American Ministry Office already has in place. She said “the conversations that we (the committee) have had have been to try to provide some insight to Fr. Bob on how he might approach the problem. There’s been some conversation about the publicity, how the media can assist in the effort, what publications we could put messages in concerning the history of black religious and clergy. The folks involved this time truly have some vision and some insight that can at least give Fr. Stiefvater support in what he’s trying to do.”

Fr. Stiefvater added that the competition from the secular world is keen.

“One of the things we were very aware of in the last plan was that for many of the African-American students who did well academically in our Catholic high schools, they were already, in a sense, ‘taken’ by industry by the time they were juniors in high school, which is when I’d be focusing a lot of my material.”

Colleges traditionally begin mailings in October of a student’s junior year. “They get inundated by stuff from colleges,” Fr. Stiefvater said. “I wanted to make sure I was on the platter, so to speak, so I had to get to young people much earlier.”

Studies of those who pursue church vocations show that fourth through sixth grades, the junior year of high school, and halfway through college are “real impact points,” Fr. Stiefvater said. “Those are points when you’re beginning to make different types of decisions about your future.”

Fr. Stiefvater tries to celebrate Mass four times a year at the predominantly African-American parishes of All Saints and St. Martin de Porres, and the tri-parish cluster of St. Michael, St. Francis of Assisi, and St. Rose, all in Milwaukee.

“I do that because I want people to get to know me and feel comfortable with who I am, so that I’m not a stranger to them, neither to parents nor to potential candidates. I want to be accessible.”

Fr. Bryan Massingale, a professor of moral theology at Saint Francis Seminary and the only one of the three African-American priests ordained for the archdiocese who is currently serving here, sees that as a good idea.

“Many members of the African-American community may be hesitant to support a young man’s call if they perceive the church is somehow hostile or unfriendly to their young man, to their friend or family member,” he said. “I remember when the vocation director first met with my parents, for example, the first question my mother asked the vocation director is ‘who’s going to take care of my son? Will people treat him mean?’ I think the seminary and the vocation person now need to be very sensitive and aware and supportive, and let the community know they’re sensitive and aware and supportive, if they want vocations from the African-American community.

“I think now we’re much more sensitive to the need to have diversity in the presbyterate than we were (when he was ordained in 1983),” added Fr. Massingale. “(But) there’s still a need for the Catholic Church to more proactively listen to the needs and concerns of black Catholics if they want to make the Catholic Church and the priesthood more attractive to African-Americans.”

Deacon Troy Major of St. Michael, St. Francis and St. Rose, one of only a few African-American deacons in the Archdiocese of Milwaukee, said, “Our parish is a little different than the other African-American parishes as far as not being exposed to African-Americans in front of the pulpit. The priests we have do a pretty good job trying to hold it together, but there’s a sense of a lack of color and of sensitivity to the black community.”

Deacon Major currently is interviewing two finalists for a half-time position as an African-American minister for the tri-parish cluster.

“There’s Laotian ministers, ministers to Asian people, people for Spanish, but there was no one there for African-Americans. There (used to be) one, but it was dropped in favor of a youth minister, with the intent to hire someone for the African-American ministry, which laid in limbo for a couple of years. We were just trying to make that possible again,” he said.

According to Deacon Major, the person in the position is expected “primarily to evangelize the African-American people in the community, in the parish, find out why they have dropped out of church, bring them back to church, promote vocations in the church, give (people) a sense of empowerment.”

Deacon Major added, “Some of the other communities are struggling with some of the same concerns we have — the lack of black visible (priest) leadership in the pulpit and visual support from black sisters, brothers, and deacons, people that are a little more sensitive to the African-American needs in the Catholic community.”

Fr. Massingale said while the respect and support he receives from the African-American community and the “great majority” of priests in the archdiocese is heartening, “I would be lying if I said I never experience any prejudice. There are times when people look at you strange, like ‘what is that black face doing behind the collar?’” He thinks support is just as necessary as the call from God in order to survive in a vocation.

Fr. Massingale finds it among other African-American religious brothers and sisters in the archdiocese, other black priest friends around the country with whom he keeps regular phone and e-mail contact, and “other friends, who happen to be white, who over the years have learned to be sensitive and aware to my struggles as a black man, and they are a great support to me as well. But I would say that as an African-American priest, you do have to intentionally and consciously create those support systems for yourself. You can’t depend on the church to create them for you.”
Back to the top